Yankees-Dodgers Trade Rumor: Is Dustin May Really Headed to the Bronx?
In a shocking turn of events, rumors are swirling about a potential blockbuster trade between the New York Yankees and the Los Angeles Dodgers involving right-handed pitcher Dustin May. At 27 years old, May has shown flashes of brilliance on the mound with his electric stuff, but injuries have plagued his young career. If this trade were to happen, it could be a high-risk, high-reward move for the Yankees as they seek to solidify their rotation for the 2025 season.
However, as of now, there is no official confirmation that this trade has actually taken place. Dustin May remains under contract with the Dodgers after signing a one-year, $2.135 million deal in November 2024 to avoid arbitration. Given his recent injury history—including Tommy John surgery in 2023 and an esophagus repair in 2024—May has not pitched in a major league game since early 2023. That raises the question: Would the Yankees really make a move for an injury-prone pitcher who has yet to prove he can return to form?
From the Yankees’ perspective, adding a dynamic arm like May could provide a much-needed boost to a rotation that struggled with consistency last season. The Bronx Bombers already have a strong foundation with Gerrit Cole leading the staff, and adding another high-upside pitcher could help them make a deep playoff run. If healthy, May has the potential to be a frontline starter. His mid-to-upper 90s fastball and devastating breaking pitches make him a nightmare for hitters when he’s at his best.
But health is a major concern. May’s injury history is extensive, and he has thrown just 33 innings since the start of the 2022 season. If the Yankees were to acquire him, they would need to have confidence in their medical staff’s ability to get him back to full strength. Additionally, the cost of acquiring him remains unknown. Would the Yankees have to give up a promising prospect? Would the Dodgers be willing to part with May for a minimal return, given his injury history?
For the Dodgers, moving May could make sense if they are looking to clear roster space for other pitchers or if they feel he is unlikely to regain his pre-injury form. They have one of the deepest pitching staffs in baseball and might view May as an expendable asset. However, they also have invested years in his development and may prefer to see if he can bounce back.
As exciting as this potential trade sounds, all current evidence suggests it has not happened—at least not yet. Fans should be cautious when reading unverified rumors. Until an official announcement is made by either team, Dustin May remains a Dodger, and the Yankees will have to look elsewhere if they want to bolster their starting rotation.
For now, Yankees fans should focus on the upcoming games and their team’s push for a strong start to the season. If a trade for May does happen, it will certainly be one of the most talked-about moves of the year.