The Los Angeles Dodgers made a surprising move by trading veteran reliever Ryan Brasier to the Chicago Cubs. The trade, which involved either cash considerations or a player to be named later, has sparked debate among MLB fans, with many divided on whether the decision was a wise one. Some believe that parting with Brasier is a major mistake, while others argue that the move was inevitable given the Dodgers’ recent bullpen acquisitions.
Brasier, 37, played a key role in the Dodgers’ bullpen during their 2024 World Series-winning season. After being designated for assignment by the Boston Red Sox in early 2023, he revitalized his career with the Dodgers, posting a 3.54 ERA over 29 regular-season appearances last year. His postseason experience, having also won a World Series with the Red Sox in 2018, made him a valuable piece of the Dodgers’ relief corps.
Despite Brasier’s contributions, the Dodgers made several offseason moves to bolster their bullpen, signing relievers like Kirby Yates and Tanner Scott. These additions pushed Brasier out of the team’s plans, leading to his designation for assignment before the trade. While some fans expected him to return on a minor league deal, the Dodgers instead finalized a trade with the Cubs, sending him to Chicago along with some cash to cover part of his salary.
The decision to trade Brasier has divided Dodgers fans. Supporters of the move argue that with the team’s new bullpen acquisitions, Brasier was expendable. The Dodgers have prioritized a younger, more dominant bullpen, making the trade a logical step in reshaping their roster. Additionally, Brasier’s age and declining velocity raised concerns about his long-term effectiveness.
However, many fans believe the trade is a mistake, pointing to Brasier’s reliability and playoff experience. With a World Series-winning pedigree, Brasier brought leadership and stability to the Dodgers’ bullpen, and some feel that letting him go could weaken their late-game pitching options. His ability to handle high-pressure situations, particularly in the postseason, made him a valuable asset, and critics argue that the Dodgers may regret losing a veteran presence.
For the Cubs, acquiring Brasier is a low-risk move that could pay off significantly. Chicago has been looking to solidify its bullpen depth, and adding an experienced reliever with championship experience fits well with their plans. To make room for Brasier on the roster, the Cubs designated left-hander Rob Zastryzny for assignment.
If Brasier can maintain the form he showed with the Dodgers last season, he could be a crucial part of the Cubs’ bullpen in 2025. His ability to get key outs in late-inning situations will be valuable as the Cubs look to compete in a challenging National League Central division.
While only time will tell whether the Dodgers made the right decision, the trade has certainly generated strong reactions among MLB fans. Whether Brasier thrives in Chicago or struggles remains to be seen, but for now, the debate over this move continues to divide baseball enthusiasts.