The Atlanta Braves are facing a heated competition for the starting shortstop role, with Orlando Arcia, Vaughn Grissom, and Braden Shewmake battling for the position. As the team approaches the 2025 season, the decision will be crucial in shaping their infield defense and offensive production.
Orlando Arcia: The Incumbent Starter
Orlando Arcia took over the shortstop role last season and delivered a solid offensive performance. In 58 plate appearances, he posted a strong .358/.414/.547 slash line. However, despite his offensive contributions, Arcia’s defensive metrics have been below average, leading to concerns about his reliability at shortstop. If his bat stays consistent, he could retain the starting job, but the Braves may seek stronger defensive alternatives.
Vaughn Grissom: The Offensive Upside
Vaughn Grissom has been a promising young player for Atlanta, known for his offensive skills. However, his defense at shortstop has been a concern. His footwork and range have not met the standard expected at the position, raising questions about whether he would be better suited for a different infield role. If Grissom can improve his defense in spring training, he could become a serious contender for the job.
Braden Shewmake: The Defensive Specialist
Braden Shewmake is regarded as the best defensive option among the three. His glove work and range make him a natural fit for shortstop, but his offensive production has lagged behind. In Triple-A, he slashed .243/.282/.456, showing some power but lacking consistency. If the Braves prioritize defense, Shewmake could get the nod, though his bat remains a question mark.
External Options: Willy Adames and Others
The Braves have also been linked to free-agent shortstop Willy Adames. At 29, Adames brings power to the lineup, having hit 32 home runs with a .251/.331/.462 slash line last season. However, his defensive performance declined in 2024, making him a risky investment. The Braves must decide whether to pursue an upgrade externally or stick with their internal options.
Fan Sentiment and Team Priorities
Fan opinion has shifted over the offseason. Initially, 61% of Braves fans believed the team should prioritize upgrading the shortstop position. However, recent polls show that 55% now view acquiring a starting pitcher as a greater priority.
As spring training continues, the battle for the starting shortstop position remains one of the most intriguing storylines for the Braves, with offensive production, defensive reliability, and potential acquisitions all in play.